Within the last 10 years, the church building has been refurbished by replacing the original roof with a slate roof, addition of a handicap ramp and terrace to the front of the church, enlarging the pastor's study, adding restrooms to the main floor of the church and enlarging the restrooms in the basement, addition of a new heating/air conditioning system, placement of new flooring in the vestibule and kitchen, and addition of new counter tops in the kitchen. Work continues to make the church building more accessible and user-friendly for the congregation and the community.
Thirty-two men have served as pastor to the congregation in either a full-time, supply, or interim relationship since 1866:
Thomas D. Bell 1866-1873
J. Rice Bowman 1866-1873
Robert H. Fleming 1874-1876
John A. Preston 1876-1883
Lamartine H. Paul 1884-1888
L. W. Irwin (student) 1888-1890
William C. Hogan 1890-1893
F. J. Brooke (supply) 1894
J. Spencer Smith 1895-1901
Ivanhoe Robertson 1902-1904
Samuel S. Oliver 1905-1908
Clarence R. Lacy 1910-1919
Albert P. Dickson 1919-1924
Roy Smith 1925-1927
Leslie H. Patterson 1927-1936
Delemo L. Beard 1936-1943
Jesse W. Myers 1943-1945
Delemo L. Beard 1946-1947
John E. Thompson 1948-1949
James M. McDaniel 1950-1956
Jonathan Edwards 1957-1962
J. Wilson Rowe, Jr. 1963-1970
George L. Oehler 1972-1976
Donald S. Wilkinson 1977-1985
James M. Hovland 1986-1991
Charles K. Reller (interim)1991-1992
Terry Mosholder 1992-1993
Charles K. Reller 1993-1994
Richard O. Young (interim) 1995-1996
Brian D. Weger 1996-2000
Mark Fisher (supply) 2001
Richard O. Young (interim) 2002-2003
William G. Everhart (supply) 2003
Richard O. Young (interim) 2004
Kenneth P. Haines (supply) 2004-2005
Kevin L. Hand 2005-